Section 31 Is a Mediocre Action Movie, and an Even Worse Star Trek One

It’s now 14 Star Trek Over the past 50 years the movie and still the franchise has always had a bit of a reputation for cinematic struggles on the big screen. From the filmic continuation of the original show to the Calvin timeline reboot, Star Trek There’s always been the question of how you adapt a TV series that boasts diplomatic diplomacy and a meeting of scientific minds into a blockbuster media that boasts sci-fi action spectacle. can Star Trek still be Star Trek In such an environment? With its arrival this week Section 31 On Paramount+Another question is boldly asked instead: What if a Star Trek One was not interested in being a movie Star Trek Is the movie or even a particularly interesting action one?

Section 31 Took a long way to be one The first teased TV spinoff of Star TrekThen came the streaming era discoveryIts first season, before disappearing into the shadows and re-emerging as a film vehicle years later Now-Oscar winner Michelle YeohA bumpy ride was deeply felt throughout the nearly two-hour runtime. Yeo is playing his role discovery Character Philippa Georgiou’s ex-emperor Trekof Alternate mirror universePart of his time on the show is re-examined and redeemed before he is sent off to an unknown time to live a new life—the movie follows Georgiou as he is forced to cross paths with the titular agents. Black Ops spy agency first introduction Deep Space NineAnd with ties to his bloody past, the Federation has offered him a place on a dangerous mission beyond the edges of space.

That team consists of an eclectic mix of characters—led by Straight Light (Omari Hardwick); his right-hand man and strong-arm, mechsuit-wearing Jeff (Rob Kaczynski); shapeshifting team genius Quasi (Sam Richardson); Deltan operative Mele (Humberly Gonzalez); Wild Card Fudge (Sven Ruygrok); and their Starfleet overseer Rachel Garrett (Casey Rohl, playing a younger version of Tricia O’Neill’s captain enterprise– from c next generationof “Yesterday’s Enterprise”) who, along with Yeo, can spend the next few hours running, shooting, and tearing their way through a galactic threat plot. And that’s really its vibe Section 31: It’s a little less James Bond, and a little more Guardians of the Galaxy, If the latter series forgets to maintain any sense of sincerity based on its quirky humor. This could be fine, it wasn’t Star Trek movie title Section 31—which it is, so it’s not right, and we’ll see why later. But as a Star Trek movie title Section 31It is an inquisitive trade in and about his world It is named for the organization Instead of wrapping itself in a flashy, but ultimately hollow sci-fi aesthetic.

Section 31 Deeply wants to convey to its audience that its heroes are great, what they’re doing is great, and even that they’re all unusual for what we expect. Star Trek Heroes, they’re cooler for being so. Garrett, as the only official Starfleet officer among them, has to straddle this line of team stick-in-the-mud—”to ensure Starfleet that no one here commits murder,” he snaps during his introductory scene—though he’s kooky enough to be one of the gang, which feels emblematic of the film’s fundamental failure. It’s so eager, desperate even, to communicate its strange tone that it forgets to ask anything remotely interesting about its premise, or the intent loaded behind its title as a film about Section 31 and its place. Star Trekits universe.

Don’t get involved with movies even once Controversial legacy Section 31 In Star Trek history, nor does it ever really show its protagonists walking the kind of moral line that would make them anything other than unstoppable heroes: the most that is presented to the audience to hint at is that this is an unsanctioned-design entity. only The team’s mission is set outside the borders of the Federation, as it were Star Trek He has not sent his regular heroes across the boarder countless times before. Section 31 Acting as if all of this is bold and new for the franchise, while simultaneously ignoring the reality that might make it at least interesting: examining what those who live and breathe Section 31 actually think about the organization and its place within the Federation, and destruction. At what cost to protect a utopia from the hands of those willing to bend those ideals.

if Star Trek A series that ponders big ideas and asks big questions, Section 31 Obsessed with the short, because it’s easier to make a disgusting joke than to reckon with the complex concepts behind the series’ exploration of the past. All this may sound like lambasting Section 31 To be a film that it is not, and probably never will be, but it reflects the lack of curiosity felt throughout the film. Its characters are threadbare beyond being presented as quirky and fun in their surface-level capacities – no matter how good the supporting cast is, anchored around a fun, but equally underwhelming performance by Michelle Yeoh, as Georgiou gets most of the film’s character work. It plays off a series of tropes of the spy-fi genre, from betrayal to subterfuge and interrogation, but it’s less about actually playing with those tropes. Star TrekIts setting and so much more is only to point to them as it shuts them down. Its pacing is awkward and jerky, moving from one moment to the next so quickly that the film doesn’t allow anything meaningful to happen with its characters or plot twists. to convey

This lack of curiosity can be at least somewhat forgivable Section 31 At least there was a good action movie, but unfortunately it floundered there too. The handful of action sequences throughout have some interesting ideas, and yes, Yeh revels in all of those sequences—there’s high stakes, even if some of them drag on a bit longer than they’d necessarily welcome. But these interesting ideas are often undermined by poor cinematography and editing that often obscures the impact of the action, leaving them hollow.

All this to say that this is not a lawsuit Section 31 Being different from what is expected Star TrekAnd so bad for that reason. Instead, it’s simply a film that struggles to carve out any kind of meaningful identity for itself, even as it ignores one that it could broadly establish. Star Trek Suffrage, regardless of whether it ultimately stands in opposition to or resembles it. A film that clocks in at just over two hours probably shouldn’t feel like a slog, but Section 31 There are no surprises to shock viewers from its anemic character work, nor thematic meat on its bones for them to sit and chew on. Instead, beneath its skin-deep weirdness, the only thing lurking in the shadows here isn’t a secret, morally-compromised spy ring: instead, it’s a pretty dull movie.

Star Trek: Episode 31 Starts streaming this Friday, January 24 on Paramount+.

Want more io9 news? See when the latest is expected Marvel, Star WarsAnd Star Trek What’s next for the release? The DC Universe in Film and TVAnd everything you need to know about its future Who is the doctor?.